As we celebrate the birth of our nation this week, I encourage you to take a few moments between barbecuing and enjoying fireworks to also toast the beginnings of intellectual property rights for Americans.
While not tied to July 4 specifically, the first baby steps of U.S. IP law were laid down in the Constitution, right there in Article 1, Section 8. Commonly known as the Intellectual Property Clause, it states:
“To promote the progress of science and useful arts, by securing for limited times to authors and inventors the exclusive right to their respective writings and discoveries.”
What does it mean, and how did it come to be? First, we should dig a bit deeper into that legalese.
US Copyright and Patent Law Takes Its First Steps
To really understand the Intellectual Property Clause, you need to break it down into its component parts:
- “To promote the progress of science and useful arts…” This opening phrase outlines the clause’s purpose: to encourage advancements in knowledge, technology, and the arts. Unlike how many people think of IP protection today, they were not creating a system simply to reward individual creators, but to foster contributions that benefit society as a whole. In other words, by giving creators a temporary advantage, we are incentivizing innovation that ultimately serves the public good.
- “…by securing for limited times…” This section emphasizes that the rights granted to creators are not indefinite. Copyrights and patents expire after a set period, allowing the work or invention to enter the public domain. This ensures that others can freely use, adapt, and build upon those creations, fueling ongoing progress and cultural development.
- “…to authors and inventors the exclusive right to their respective writings and discoveries.” Here, the clause defines who is protected and what is covered. Authors (including writers, artists, and composers) receive copyright protection for their creative works. Inventors, on the other hand, are eligible for patent protection, which applies to new and useful inventions and processes. These protections are exclusive during the term, meaning others cannot legally copy or profit from the work without permission.
The Intellectual Property Clause creates a balanced system rewarding creators for their contributions while ensuring that those contributions eventually become part of a shared pool of knowledge and creativity. For today’s business owners, artists, inventors, and innovators, understanding this balance is key to protecting your work and contributing to a larger cycle of progress.
How did the clause come to be?
What We Know About the Intellectual Property Clause
As with a number of legal and political ideas in the US, the origin of intellectual property protection began with an existing English law called the Statute of Monopolies. Created in 1623, this statute said that England’s monarch was only allowed to grant someone a monopoly in the form of letters patent for new inventions — and only then for fourteen years and if the monopoly was of societal benefit. Right there you have two of the most important pillars of American IP law:
- That individuals would have exclusive right to their work
- for a limited duration.
A version of this law actually came to Massachusetts in 1641, and various intellectual property protections were offered by a variety of colonies over the next (roughly) 150 years. However, the laws were piecemeal and protection was almost always given via someone petitioning the local legislature individually.
After the Revolutionary War, the economy evolved from mostly local to one that was increasingly national, prompting campaigning from American authors for a more formalized system of IP rights. This resulted in 12 of the 13 states creating formal IP laws, but did not fix interstate problems.
Because of this, both James Madison and Charles Pinckney proposed IP clauses at the Constitutional Convention (copyright for Madison and patent for Pinckney). After roughly a month of combining and refining the language, the IP Clause was brought before the Convention and passed without debate.
So while you are enjoying this day with your loved ones, consider all of the amazing pieces of intellectual property that make our modern Independence Day celebrations possible — and if you come up with an amazing new grill or firework, or write a new song or story about the 4th, make sure to register it.
Happy 4th of July, everyone!